🍪 BAKED FRESH DAILY IN MICHIGAN

Build Your Perfect Cookie Box

Handcrafted small batch cookies made from scratch, shipped fresh to your door or ready for pickup!

We ship orders Monday-Wednesday! Orders placed after noon on Wednesday will be shipped the following week.

Choose Your Box Size

Every box is built to order with your choice of flavors

4 Pack
4 Pack 4 Cookies $27 $6.75/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → 📍 Just $17 with local pickup!
Half Dozen
Half Dozen 6 Cookies $34 $5.67/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → Save $1.08/cookie vs. 4 Pack 📍 Just $24 with local pickup! ⭐ MOST POPULAR
One Dozen
One Dozen 12 Cookies $48 $4.00/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → Best value — save $2.75/cookie vs. 4 Pack 📍 Just $38 with local pickup!
OUR COOKIE MENU

What's Baking This Month

Pick from our rotating specialties and classic favorites

THIS MONTH'S SPECIALTIES — Limited Time

+$1
Pumpkin Cheesecake *In-store Only
Pumpkin Cheesecake *In-store Only Our pumpkin dough rolled in cinnamon sugar then topped with our homemade crea... Limited Time
+$1
Peanut Butter Lover
Peanut Butter Lover We packed this cookie with PB goodies from top to bottom - Reese's Pieces, Re... Limited Time
+$1
Apple Crisp
Apple Crisp An apple cookie topped with oatmeal crumble then finished with a vanilla glaz... Limited Time
+$1
Nutella Chocolate Chip
Nutella Chocolate Chip IT'S BACK, Nutella Lovers! Our OG chocolate chip cookie stuffed with Nutella ... Limited Time
+$1
Monster
Monster Big, thick, and absolutely LOADED with creamy peanut butter, hearty oats, m... Limited Time

CLASSIC FAVORITES — Always Available

Caramel Chocolate Chip
Caramel Chocolate Chip Buttery caramel bits, rich chocolate chips, and a little sprinkle of sea salt... Always Available
Oatmeal Raisin
Oatmeal Raisin A thick chewy cookie loaded with oats and raisins!  Always Available
Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip
Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Our first ever vegan-friendly option! *Made in a facility that handles butter... Always Available
Snickerdoodle
Snickerdoodle Our sugar cookie base rolled in cinnamon-sugar Always Available
Not Your Mama’s Peanut Butter
Not Your Mama’s Peanut Butter A thick and chewy peanut butter cookie loaded with peanut butter chips Always Available
Cake Batter
Cake Batter Confetti Sprinkles & White Chocolate Chips Always Available
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip The OG, the cookie that started JoJo's Cookie Co.! Always Available
Lemon
Lemon A lemon sugar cookie topped with lemon glaze. Always Available
Fudge Chocolate
Fudge Chocolate Fudgey brownie-like cookie Always Available
Lemon-Glazed Molasses
Lemon-Glazed Molasses A thick, chewy molasses cookie topped with lemon glaze. The PERFECT combination. Always Available
Triple Chip
Triple Chip This cookie is packed with dark chocolate, white chocolate & milk chocola... Always Available
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip Our first ever gluten-friendly option! Trust us, it was worth the wait.  *Mad... Always Available
Famous Sugar
Famous Sugar Our famous sugar cookie with homemade buttercream frosting and topped with sp... Always Available
🚚
Fast Shipping
FedEx 2-Day to all 50 states. $12.50 flat rate, free over $80.
🏪
Local Pickup — Save $10
Pick up in Petoskey or Traverse City and save $10 at checkout.
🍪
Baked Fresh to Order
Every cookie is handcrafted from scratch using premium ingredients.
⭐
As Seen on Today Show
Featured nationally in 2023. 22K+ happy customers on Instagram.
🎉 First time ordering? Use code WELCOME10 for 10% off your first order!