🍪 BAKED FRESH DAILY IN MICHIGAN

Build Your Perfect Cookie Box

Handcrafted small batch cookies made from scratch, shipped fresh to your door or ready for pickup. Choose your box size and pick your favorites!

Choose Your Box Size

Every box is built to order with your choice of flavors

4 Pack
4 Pack 4 Cookies $27 $6.75/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → 📍 Just $17 with local pickup!
Half Dozen
Half Dozen 6 Cookies $34 $5.67/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → Save $1.08/cookie vs. 4 Pack 📍 Just $24 with local pickup! ⭐ MOST POPULAR
One Dozen
One Dozen 12 Cookies $48 $4.00/cookie BUILD YOUR BOX → Best value — save $2.75/cookie vs. 4 Pack 📍 Just $38 with local pickup!
OUR COOKIE MENU

What's Baking This Month

Pick from our rotating specialties and classic favorites

THIS MONTH'S SPECIALTIES — Limited Time

+$1
Dot Cookie
Dot Cookie Our Cake Batter cookie topped with homemade vanilla buttercream and dipped in... Limited Time
+$1
Cherry Pie *Local Pickup Only
Cherry Pie *Local Pickup Only Our sugar cookie stuffed with a cherry pie filling and topped with vanilla gl... Limited Time
+$1
Loaded Smore *Local Pickup Only
Loaded Smore *Local Pickup Only The summer fan favorite! Cinnamon dough loaded with chocolate chips, then stu... Limited Time
+$1
TC Cherry Chocolate Oatmeal
TC Cherry Chocolate Oatmeal An oatmeal base cookie with cherries & dark chocolate. Just in time for T... Limited Time
+$1
M&M Brownie
M&M Brownie Our classic chewy chocolate chip cookie, generously STUFFED with a rich, fudg... Limited Time

CLASSIC FAVORITES — Always Available

Oatmeal Raisin
Oatmeal Raisin A thick chewy cookie loaded with oats and raisins!  Always Available
Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip
Vegan-Friendly Chocolate Chip Our first ever vegan-friendly option! *Made in a facility that handles butter... Always Available
Snickerdoodle
Snickerdoodle Our sugar cookie base rolled in cinnamon-sugar Always Available
Not Your Mama’s Peanut Butter
Not Your Mama’s Peanut Butter A thick and chewy peanut butter cookie loaded with peanut butter chips Always Available
Cake Batter
Cake Batter Confetti Sprinkles & White Chocolate Chips Always Available
Chocolate Chip
Chocolate Chip The OG, the cookie that started JoJo's Cookie Co.! Always Available
Lemon
Lemon A lemon sugar cookie topped with lemon glaze. Always Available
Fudge Chocolate
Fudge Chocolate Fudgey brownie-like cookie Always Available
Lemon-Glazed Molasses
Lemon-Glazed Molasses A thick, chewy molasses cookie topped with lemon glaze. The PERFECT combination. Always Available
Triple Chip
Triple Chip This cookie is packed with dark chocolate, white chocolate & milk chocola... Always Available
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip
Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Chip Our first ever gluten-friendly option! Trust us, it was worth the wait.  *Mad... Always Available
Kitchen Sink
Kitchen Sink Our chocolate chip cookie dough base packed with toffee bits, caramel pieces ... Always Available
Famous Sugar
Famous Sugar Our famous sugar cookie with homemade buttercream frosting and topped with sp... Always Available
🚚
Fast Shipping
FedEx 2-Day to all 50 states. $12.50 flat rate, free over $80.
🏪
Local Pickup — Save $10
Pick up in Petoskey or Traverse City and save $10 at checkout.
🍪
Baked Fresh to Order
Every cookie is handcrafted from scratch using premium ingredients.
⭐
As Seen on Today Show
Featured nationally in 2023. 22K+ happy customers on Instagram.
🎉 First time ordering? Use code WELCOME10 for 10% off your first order!