Perfectly Baked, Perfectly Delicious

Smiles from Scratch

PETOSKEY | TRAVERSE CITY | NATIONWIDE
ORDER NOW

March Featured Cookies

AVAILABLE UNTIL SOLD OUT

Thick Mint

Our Mint Fudge dough topped with a mint chocolate ganache — all the March Mint you need right here!

Monster

This cookie is loaded with peanut butter, oats, chocolate chips & m&m’s — it’s the perfect salty sweet combination & frequently requested all year round!

Birthday Batter

We turn FOUR this month! Help us celebrate with this cookie — our JoJo’s Blue Cake Batter cookie stuffed with an ooey gooey brownie center. All the batter you need!

PB Chocolate Cream Pie

Two Not Your Mama’s Peanut Butter cookies sandwich’d with our homemade chocolate buttercream in the middle. Chocolate Peanut Butter fans — THIS is your cookie!

Lucky Charm

Your favorite St Paddy inspired cookie IS BACK! Lucky Charms & white chocolate throughout the dough, topped with a marshmallow fluff / white chocolate ganache & MORE Lucky Charms on top!

ORDER NOW
VIEW ALL COOKIES